This password will be used to sign into all, Okay, TikTok, You Can Calm Down About Aubrey Plaza at the SAG Awards Now, Shakira Takes Some Pointers From Taylor Swift, All 165 Pink Floyd Songs Ranked, From Worst to Best, Kristen Bell to Befriend an Unorthodox Rabbi. SPOILER ALERT: Do not read if you have not yet watched "Falling," the penultimate episode of "Sharp Objects." The characters in "Sharp Objects" are all hiding se To make matters worse, the flashbacks to Camille's childhood detail everything from her discovering a frightening shed in the woods to an instance of apparent sexual assault. Whereas on the HBO drama, we actually see a dark glimpse of our heroine's abusive past, in a scene that shows a preteen Camille in her cheerleading uniform, being hunted down in the woods by boys who go on to gang rape her in broad daylight. The last few lines of the article that Camille writes and Curry reads aloud on the show are actually the last lines of the novel. He's been working for Collider for over a decade, and in addition to managing content also runs point on crafts interviews, awards coverage, and co-hosts The Collider Podcast with Matt Goldberg (which has been running since 2012). I think Amy and Patty made me a better actor. While Ann's body was found in Wind Gap's adjoining woods, Natalie's was presented for the entire town to see, making the killer's motive and style much more difficult to pin down as Camille and the police try to investigate. Natalie bit Meredith's earlobe one night while she was sleeping at the Keene house. It was so many emotions, just like you said. But as a result, fans were left with a lot of unresolved questions after the final episode of the limited series. This scene gave me hope - Camille finally chose to explore a different outcome in Wind Gap by changing the dynamics of a scene she had already participated in before. Well, not outside of pop psych.). Spoilers abound, obviously. And partly his heart is getting involved. She starts cutting again, on the few spots she still has left on her body. I dont think hes as damaged as she is, or in as much pain. But we just wanted to age her up a tiny bit because of some of the parts in the book that are you know -- visually it's different to see it than to read it, we might even age her up in your head a little bit. So its fun to know those little bits and pieces are there. Was I good at caring for Amma because of kindness? I thought it was really good. And then the surprise of oh, and there is someone still doing it or still out there a victim in this did feel like its own coda, in a way. In the novel, Camille also has no closure with Richard. We're not straying from spoilers in here. And I was like, no way.I think the viewers will feel betrayed if theyve been kept out of her secret for that long. Read more about it over here. Showrunner Marti Noxon said that the decision to age Amma up was in part to make sure viewers wouldn't be distracted by her youth. But even in the short time we've spoken, it's clear that Messina genuinely wants to engage. But in the novelization of the scene, Meredith (aka Ashley) admits that it was actually Natalie who did it, further revealing that both Natalie and Ann were known "biters.". "I dont know if I answered your questions well enough," he says, winding back to our discussion about #MeToo. Create an account to follow your favorite communities and start taking part in conversations. This behavior is in line with her playing dress up as Persephone, the Greek goddess who is kidnapped and held captive in the underworld by the god of death, Hades. And while Noxon and Flynn worked closely. Ground it back and forth until the skin was shredded in scribbly cuts. Oh, and why they settled on those final three words that will haunt you until the end of time. At one point Ashley offhandedly tells Camille that her sister was pissed that John had moved into the carriage house, because that's where she and her "nasty friends" (including Amma) used to hang out. It was sad. Changing it would be sort of mystifying.. He had moved in with Ashley after his sister's death to keep an eye on Amma and her crew. This recontextualizes the ending and positions Amma not as a lone sociopath, but the leader of a pack of sociopaths so to speak. Richard and Camille are very alike. With the ramifications of the finale, there would be other things to tell. When you consider the number of themes that repeat themselves over time in the series, this scene actually pops out as a big breakthrough moment for Camille. Thats the real answer to the whodunit. As the final image in the credits scene reveals: Yes, the woman in white that little James Caprisi claims to have seen luring Natalie away into the woods was totally real. As he and Camille bond over their "outsider" statusand the information they can give one anotheran attraction forms between them, and soon they begin sleeping together. On Sharp Objects, it surely can't be a mistake that the word is spelled out with literal pins. And don't say we didn't warn you about those darker differences. The finale of HBOs adaptation of Gillian Flynns Sharp Objects ended with the reveal that even though Adora (Patricia Clarkson) had killed her daughter Marian and was finally sent to jail for her crimes she wasnt the one who murdered Natalie and Ann. They died at almost exactly the same time, about a year after Camille was born. So shes still walking that crazy line between trying to emulate Adora, literally by murdering, but also by not having the emotional capacity to do it with any subtlety or even deal with the consequences. Also Read: Sharp Objects': Showrunner Marti Noxon Says Calhoun Day Started Out as a Joke. Wed hurt things together. And there was so much more that I wanted to know about the other part. Its incredibly fast and hard to make out much, but we absolutely see that Amma and her roller skating friends definitely killed Ann together, as the others held her down while Amma strangled her. Viewers of the TV adaptation find out Camille (Amy Adams) is a cutter, who has marks covering nearly her whole body at the end of the premiere episode -- but it takes readers about 60 pages to get to that revelation. Also that she had been right that John did not kill the little girls. Terms of Service apply. Their last scene with one another was touching and so much was said outside of their dialogue, and I think there was a genuine affection there, and I liked them as a pair. In the novel, Amma is only 13 years old, though the actress who plays her, Eliza Scanlen, is 19 in real life. Id like to think that she and John go on to have a happy, healthy and loving relationship. They were notorious for bouts of aggression. If you didn't watch through the credits, you missed a crucial detail. In the bathroom, she explains, I stripped off my shirt and dug it deep into the perfect circle on my back. Here, we explain the entire ending and what happens to Camille and the Preaker family. Detective Richard Willis is a detective from Kansas City who has been brought to Wind Gap to assist in the investigation of Ann and Natalie's murders. Probably almost all of it at that age. People do that to fuck it up beyond repair and avoid being one of those dreadful couples in a toxic relationship constantly off and on again. While Amma's friends get lighter sentences for coming forward with their testimonies, Amma is found guilty of first-degree murder and it's said she will remain locked up until her eighteenth birthday (and likely longer). And he just walks away? 17-Down, Three Letters: Party for One artist Carly ___ Jepsen. And book spoilers here but, in Flynns source material, this is the same endingAmma killed Ann and Natalie with the help of her friends. Finally, as the credits end, there's one brief shot of Amma in a white dress. In the aftermath of their mother's arrest, Camille brings Amma to live with her in St. Louis, giving her a fresh start far away from Wind Gap. And depending on her emotional and physical maturity, you can imagine something for a girl who looks a certain age and not with others. Camille, having briefly escaped her mother's clutches, goes out to search for John Keene, who's the subject of a police manhunt. Alan sells the house for a place closer to the prison, and writes to his still-beloved wife on the days he can't visit her in person. But in the book, Adora's (Patricia Clarkson) husband feels far more distant and much less sympathetic. But while Camille is obsessed with her rock playlist -- and carries that cracked iPod with her everywhere -- there's no mention of her musical preferences in the book. But then in high school, girls were like, So, I hear you dance." He finishes the anecdote with a quirk of his eyebrow. Every item on this page was chosen by an ELLE editor. In the show Alan briefly mentions Adora's mother, Joya, and how she used to go into Adora's room at night to pinch her daughter to make sure she was still alive -- which sounds like the kind of unstable behavior Adora herself demonstrates toward her daughters later. Cookies help us deliver our Services. The show doesn't get into the true meaning behind these words. Id work with these people for the next 20 years. While that ending is probably enough to disturb you for years to come, Flynns debut novel closed a little differently. Youre lucky when you have that kind of flow. Also Read: Sharp Objects Showrunner Says No to Season 2: This Is It, We don't learn how Amma murdered Natalie and Ann. She drives to the Keene house and rings the doorbellNatalie's mother answers the door and lets Camille in as soon as Camille says she wants to talk about Natalie. Natalie's murder was almost the exact same, except they held her in the carriage house for 48 hours, playing dress up and torturing her. We were all in agreement that we wanted it to be faithful to the book, she explained in a Vulture interview. I said the exact same thing, almost made this same post. When she finds him in a hotel room, the two have sex, and when. An important detail show watchers might've missed is that Ashley (aka Meredith) is actually the older sister of one of Amma's friends -- which is why they're so often together in the same group. By using our Services, you agree to our use of cookies. Adora tells the story of her mother leaving her out in the woods at 7 or 8 years old. I love that about the character, because hes flawed. There's no such levity even in the high-school halls of Sharp Objects; the series is based on Gillian Flynn's 2006 novel, the first in an oeuvre featuring dark and damaged women. Jess is an LA-based culture critic who covers intimacy in the digital age, from sex and relationship to weed and all media (tv, games, film, the web). This is actually left much more unclear in the book, but there are several moments in the show that indicate Adora did know (or at least suspected) that Amma was the killer. Adora also stopped getting sick after her mom died. Unless we're counting those violent flashes in the finale's post-credits scenes, viewers don't find out how Amma took those young girls' lives. Sharp Objects HD CC Drama 2018 $27.99 EPISODE 1 Vanish Series premiere. Still, with due respect to The Atlantic's Sophie Gilbert, who recently inveighed against the "trope of the unethical female journalist," I think "Sharp Objects" is up to something a little different here. For years, she's been carving words that trigger her into her body, including "vanish," "cherry," and "fornicate." HBO Max Comedies Thatll Put You in a Good Mood, Everything to Know Ahead of 'Mando' Season 3, Here Are the Best Shows On HBO Max Right Now, Last of Us Star Pedro Pascal Posts Upsetting IG. Camillle & Marian waving at the guys in front of the barber shop as the roll through town on skates in E01/Chief Vickery driving through town replicating the exact same sequence a few episodes later, the celebration of rape culture of Calhoun Day/the celebration of rape culture in The End Zone, character assasination of Camille by gossip during her youth/character assasination of John by gossip 20 years later, Adora's literal repeated MSBP treatment of two daughters 20 years apart). The day Amma is arrested in the novel, Camille slips a knife up her sleeve and finally cuts into the one part of her body she has left pure. Here, Noxon broke down a few of them for TheWrap. HBOs excellent miniseries adaptation of Gillian Flynns Sharp Objects has at last come to an end, but not without one last surprise. Camille is holding up one of the teeth in horror when Amma enters the room. "Im embarrassed to say I was stupid and nave and blind to anything like that," he says. As Camille and Amma wake up with brutal hangovers after their night out, Adora supplies "medicine" for both of them, which makes them feel worse. And the truth about Amma all but destroys her. Noxon said that the show's soundtrack is all thanks to director Jean-Marc Vall. By submitting your email, you agree to our Terms and Privacy Policy and to receive email correspondence from us. But there is also just the reality that this is a tough team to assemble and I think it would be pretty impossible to do it again (laughs). The flashbacks Camille keeps having revealed the moment when Marian died, as they lay in bed together telling each other stories. In the aftermath of Natalie's frightening reappearance, two suspects stand out from the rest: Ann's father, Bob Nash, and Natalie's brother, John Keene. Richard Willis is one of the characters in the book Sharp Objects and the upcoming HBO television series of the same name. The face acting from Chris Messina in that moment where he sees her scars was awesome. The Camille of the show may be about to head off into an even uglier place we just dont know but the Camille of the novel at least retains an ounce of hope. The novel and the show soften the story in different places, but ultimately, the book gives Camille a sense of closure that she lacks onscreen. But Adora had no direct involvement with the murders. But I want to be scared shitless. But you know, in the end it is a whodunit, she dun it. Throughout the flashbacks, viewers see Marian, whom Camille adored, while in the present day, Adora keeps Marian's room intact like a shrine and constantly compares Camille, who falls short of Adora's expectations in every way, to her dearly departed sister. As for Camille herself, the aftermath of Amma and Adoras imprisonment leaves her weak and susceptible in the novel. "I think if you look at his work in everything, hes very, very, music-driven," she told TheWrap (you might think of the "Big Little Lies" soundtrack). Also Read: 'Sharp Objects' Finale: Breaking Down Those Chilling Post-Credits Scenes, And the very last line Amma uttered when she walked in on her big sister discovering her victims teeth hidden inside her dollhouse was, Dont tell mama. Then the screen cuts to black and Led Zepplins In the Evening kicks into high gear as the final credits roll. In the midst of all of this, Camille strikes up an unlikely romance with Richard, the detective in charge of the murder case. *Sorry, there was a problem signing you up. Her editor Curry and his wife Eileen take her in as their own, keeping all sharp objects away from her. I wonder if the interaction would've been the same if they'd been alone. "Sharp Objects" wrapped its eight-episode run on HBO Sunday, giving you the twisted ending to Marti Noxon's take on Gillian Flynn's debut novel. 'Sharp Objects': 13 Differences Between Gillian Flynn's Novel and Amy Adams' HBO Series (Photos), 'Sharp Objects' Showrunner Says No to Season 2: 'This Is It', Why 'Sharp Objects' Showrunner Named Each Episode After a Word on Camille's Body, Sharp Objects Finale: Marti Noxon Explains the Final Line and Why They Cut the Ending Off Early, Sharp Objects': Eliza Scanlen on Playing Amy Adams Rebellious Little Sister With Balls (Video), Sharp Objects Star Eliza Scanlen Portraits (Exclusive Photos), Sharp Objects Finale: Breaking Down Those Chilling Post-Credits Scenes, Why Sharp Objects Showrunner Named Each Episode After a Word on Camilles Body, Heres How Sharp Objects Is Not Hiding Its Cuts and Looking Out for Triggers at the Same Time, Amy Adams Sharp Objects Scores 1.5 Million Viewers in HBO Debut, Sharp Objects': Patricia Clarkson Knows You Love Adora and Shes Trying Not to Judge You for It, Sharp Objects Showrunner Says No to Season 2: This Is It, Sharp Objects': Showrunner Marti Noxon Says Calhoun Day Started Out as a Joke, Sharp Objects Showrunner on Premieres Aha Moment, What Those Sharp Objects Have Done to Camille. He is seeing her and her sister, in the hospital, both poisoned by their psychopathic mother. Camille also discovers that Adora knew Ann and helped tutor her after school. Yes! I know they weren't in love, in a long term relationship, but somehow a bit of compassion beyond "I'm sorry" seemed called for. [1] The novel follows Camille Preaker, a newspaper journalist who must return to her hometown to report on a series of brutal murders. A fittingly wild ending to a crazy, wholly engrossing ride. .css-5rg4gn{display:block;font-family:NeueHaasUnica,Arial,sans-serif;font-weight:normal;margin-bottom:0.3125rem;margin-top:0;-webkit-text-decoration:none;text-decoration:none;}@media (any-hover: hover){.css-5rg4gn:hover{color:link-hover;}}@media(max-width: 48rem){.css-5rg4gn{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.3;letter-spacing:-0.02em;margin:0.75rem 0 0;}}@media(min-width: 40.625rem){.css-5rg4gn{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.3;letter-spacing:0.02rem;margin:0.9375rem 0 0;}}@media(min-width: 64rem){.css-5rg4gn{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.4;margin:0.9375rem 0 0.625rem;}}@media(min-width: 73.75rem){.css-5rg4gn{font-size:1rem;line-height:1.4;}}Aminah Nieves on Those Shocking 1923 Scenes. It's easy to look at Camille's stepfather, Alan, (played byHenry Czerny on the show) and see a "beaten spouse," as Noxon described him in a recent interview with TheWrap. I was also surprised at what I felt watching him apologize. HBO. Some might even argue its few changes make for an improved iteration of the Gone Girl. Of course, there were a few notable changes made to the story in its translation to the screen. Amma is also there, clad in a white dress and flower crown of Adora's choosing, but she's clearly ill from Adora's medicine, causing further alarm. While detective Richard failed to suspect a female could have committed the crimes, the motivations he attributed to the murderer were spot on for Amma. When Camille first arrives in Wind Gap, one young girl, 13-year-old Ann Nash, is confirmed dead, while 14-year-old Natalie Keene has been missing for days. She was somehow strong enough to escape Adora, and yet came back and ended up poisoned. Editing, a strength of the series throughout, guides viewers through to the final surprise. The whole show is in a silly, goofy mood. This Southern Gothic tale, set in the fictional town of Wind Gap, Missouri, tells the story of Camille Preaker, a troubled journalist who heads back to her hometown to investigate an unsettling string of murders. 232 votes, 29 comments. Press J to jump to the feed. Richard is on the brink of a big break in his career, and somewhat selfishly hopes that solving the case in Wind Gap . As mentioned above, yes: Amma's friends did help her execute the murders. In the final scene, Camille inspects Amma's dollhouse and finds a tooth in the model, leading to her discovering the . A barely functioning alcoholic, Camille uses booze to make it through each day, stashing vodka in her car and in her luggage to make sure she can survive any time in Wind Gap, especially under such macabre circumstances. John had no idea that he was sleeping in the exact room where his sister had been brutally tortured and mutilated by Amma and her accomplices (which included Ashley's little sister). Lets Do the Thing: How Online Were You in February 2023? Along the way, Natalie's brother, John (Taylor John Smith), also presents himself as a possible suspect. And they started to ask prying questions about why Amma was sick all the time. This also explains how Natalie's blood wound up in the carriage house where John was staying while living at Ashley's house. When Amma discovers Camille in her room, tooth in hand, the young girl simply says, "Don't tell Mama.". Adora even put a fake name for him on Camille's birth certificate: Newman Kennedy, a combination of her favorite actor (presumably Paul Newman) and president (John F. Kennedy). We killed a cat once. But then Adora began to take an interest in them. This was a better way to end it. Emily is the entertainment editor at Cosmopolitan, which is a nice way of saying she watches way too much TV and constantly wants to tell you about it. That everything in this story, thats what we get to know about. We dont see Maes body on the show only a flash of the death scene in the end credits but the book offers a vivid description of her body propped tidily next to a Dumpster Only six of her teeth had been pulled, the oversized front two and four on the bottom. Presumably, Amma ran out of time. While looking through Amma's dollhouse, which she brought to St. Louis, Camille finds pristine white teeth. Discovery to sue Paramount over 'South Park' streaming rights, Most watched movies and TV this week are are all about crime, cons, and cordyceps, 'Rogers the Musical' from 'Hawkeye' is now a real thing Disney is making, How to watch the 2023 Screen Actors Guild Awards, Wordle today: Here's the answer, hints for March 1, Prince Harry answering Stephen Colbert's quickfire questions gets into the real stuff, We need to talk about 'The Strays' bold ending, The TikTok 'bold glamour' filter is going viral for its wildly unrealistic beauty standard. Curry broke in just before I went for my face. There is no mention or glimpse of the perfect circle on the show, but it functioned in the novel as a metaphor for her restraint, that she always managed to keep it uncut (mainly because it was so difficult to reach). Unlike Marian, Amma played along. All Rights Reserved. But this didnt really make a whole lot of sense. she said, adding that he has a reputation for "exquisite" musical tastes. But if you didnt watch through the entire credits, you missed a crucial plot detail regarding the true killer. During a Sharp Objects finale credits scene, we saw flashes of the murders and learned that Amma didnt act alone. And it is in the book too. In Flynn's novel, Camille does attend rehab and has a 16-year-old girl as a roommate, who kills herself by swallowing a bottle of Windex -- but her good friend Alice is strictly a character from the show.